How to Choose the Right Lemon Law Attorney in California (2025)

If you bought a new car from a California dealership and it’s constantly breaking down, or if your vehicle issues are starting to impact the vehicle’s safety, your use, or the value of the vehicle, you might be entitled to a return of your money, a replacement, or a financial settlement through California’s Lemon Laws. An attorney can help pursue your claim, but you might wonder how to choose the right Lemon Law attorney in California.

California’s Lemon Law, officially named the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, is designed to protect consumers who may have bought a ‘lemon,’ meaning a new but defective vehicle where repetitive vehicle issues impact the safety, use, or value of their vehicle.

How Can I Choose the Right California Lemon Law Attorney?

To find the right Lemon Law attorney, it’s important to consider someone with substantial experience handling Lemon Law cases. You may want an attorney:

• With an extensive understanding of California’s Lemon Laws. An experienced attorney understands how to navigate the Lemon Law process.
• Who has a demonstrable track record of resolving these claims successfully. You can ask about their prior case results and ask about how the attorney has resolved their prior Lemon Law matters.
• Who can clearly and frequently communicate about your claim. It’s important you are able to communicate with your attorney and their staff.
• Who makes you feel heard and comfortable. You typically spend a lot of time with your attorney and you will want to feel comfortable asking them a variety of questions.
• Who can help explore all available options. It’s crucial to find an experienced attorney who understands all the legal options to resolve your vehicle’s issues.
• Who can represent your interests. Your attorney can work as a partner to fight for your legal rights and advocate for you with the manufacturer or car dealership.

When considering filing a Lemon Law claim, it’s important to meet with multiple attorneys in order to effectively compare their experience level and standard approach to these cases. Your attorney can include you as much as practical in the legal resolution of your own claim and your attorney should welcome your assistance and input with your unique case.

Of note, some attorneys have a reputation for never taking a claim to court, and car manufacturers are often keenly aware of this. If the other side of your case knows they face an attorney who won’t back down, they can be more likely to cooperate to resolve your claim in a beneficial way.

Ultimately, it’s helpful to consider an attorney who is transparent about their role in your case and who listens to your goals for Lemon Law claim resolution. Most California attorneys handling Lemon Law matters work for a contingency fee, which means they only get paid if you win.

What Should I Ask a Lemon Law Attorney I’m Considering?

There are many ways to decide whether the attorney you’re considering is the right fit for your claim. Asking many questions during an initial consultation with the attorney is important, such as:

• Have you handled many Lemon Law cases during your legal career?
• What have the outcomes been for those cases?
• Are you quite familiar with California’s Lemon Laws and the ways to resolve them?
• What strategy would you use for my specific case resolution?
• What are the potential costs and fees outlined in your written fee agreement?
• If needed, have you taken cases like mine to trial?

An experienced attorney can help resolve your unique Lemon Law claim. They can help provide peace of mind and answer any questions you might have about Lemon Laws in California and about your claim resolution.

FAQs

Q: What Is the Average Lemon Law Settlement Amount in California?

A: The average Lemon Law settlement amount in California usually varies and is dependent upon the vehicle defects, the complexity of the case, and the experience of the attorney handling your claim (if any).

A seasoned Lemon Law attorney can typically help increase the overall potential value of your settlement. A knowledgeable attorney can discuss your possible available options and help estimate the amount you might expect to get from a Lemon Law settlement.

Q: Are You Required to Retain a Lawyer for Lemon Law Claims in California?

A: You are not required to retain a lawyer for a Lemon Law claim in California. However, you might find an attorney invaluable since the process can be complicated. An attorney can help maximize the amount you get from a settlement and help make the entire experience more positive. Also, an attorney can help negotiate with involved parties. Please note, if you win your case, the vehicle manufacturer may be required to pay your legal fees.

Q: How Difficult Is It to Win a California Lemon Law Case?

A: It’s often hard to win a Lemon Law case in California because of the extensive documentation required from the consumer in order to win their case. They must keep track of documents related to the vehicle purchase, defects, and repair attempts. Consequently, it’s important to have an experienced attorney familiar with California Lemon Laws.

Although it’s not impossible to win these claims, an attorney can help maximize your likelihood of winning the case.

Q: Who Pays My Attorney Fees for a California Lemon Law Case?

A: If you win a Lemon Law case in California, the manufacturer is required to pay your attorney’s fees, legal expenses, and court costs. Accordingly, you wouldn’t have to pay out-of-pocket for attorney fees and costs or worry about whether you should represent yourself. In order to build a strong case, an attorney can listen to your concerns and help gather necessary documents.

Our California Lemon Law Attorneys Provide Statewide Free Representation

A knowledgeable Lemon Law attorney can make a significant difference in your claim resolution. They can help address any questions you might have and listen to your unique vehicle history in order to offer legal advice specifically tailored to your claim.

The legal team at Lemon Law Pro can help you with your lemon vehicle. Contact our office right away to get help from an experienced Lemon Law attorney.